# Seven-frontier HAI literature watch · 2026-11-16 KST

## Scope and authoritative inputs

- Execution window: 2025-01-01 through 2026-11-16 KST; 14-day overlap 2026-11-02–16. The morning search cannot cover later releases on the same day. Search recall and indexing delay remain limitations.
- Original HAI-research-trends.md reread in full from its persistent source, 53 lines. Its seven axes concern technical work possible without human experiments; actual overreliance, agency, subjective ownership and field outcomes require separate human evidence.
- Connected GitHub reread: baseline 2026-11-10 post, latest 2026-11-15 post, 44-item evidence register, seven-frontiers/watch_state.json, _config.yml. Today target initially 404; create one post, no duplicate schedule.
- Actual default branch master; master unprotected; repository rulesets empty. Root AGENTS.md, _posts/AGENTS.md, scoped seven-frontiers/AGENTS.md and CONTRIBUTING.md returned 404. Two recent Watch posts (Nov14/15) inspected for conventions. Current live tag navigation contains #agentic+ai and #foundation+models.
- Permalink /:year/:month/:day/:title.html; timezone Asia/Seoul. Baseline blob rechecked 62fef19e85fd336539628a48b749b982f610606d and preserved.
- Prior post public HTTP 200 and exact expected title confirmed. This is separate from today's commit/deployment.

## Search executed

Fresh web-search queries, recent engine with 14-day recency:

1. "sycophancy" "2026" November LLM research
2. "agent" "workflow" "control" "2026" paper November
3. "uncertainty" "LLM" "2026" November paper
4. "contestable" "AI" "November" "2026" paper
5. "AI" "ownership" "provenance" paper November 2026
6. "synthetic" "human" "evaluation" "2026" November paper
7. "multi-agent" coordination November 2026 research
8. "sycophancy" "correction" OR "replication" "2026"
9. "agent" "uncertainty" "retraction" OR "erratum" 2026

Full-period representative rechecks and targeted follow-up:

- 2025 2026 LLM sycophancy overreliance human experiment controlled evaluation site:aclanthology.org
- 2025 2026 agentic workflow control contestable interactive AI evaluation site:arxiv.org
- 2025 2026 uncertainty expression provenance contribution ownership human AI site:dl.acm.org
- 2025 2026 synthetic human interaction evaluation multi agent coordination site:aclanthology.org
- "contestable AI" "2025" "2026" evaluation paper (primary-domain filter)
- "AI" "ownership" "2026" "experiment" (publisher domains)
- "synthetic" "human" "evaluation" "2026" "November" (primary domains)
- Exact-title searches for N19, N20 artifact/revision, N22 artifact, P10/P11 formal publication and N17/N18 publication status; "Too Sure for Our Own Good" 184 2026.

Not every discovered candidate was incorporated. Selection favors four directly relevant primary sources whose status/claim boundaries could be checked. Search snippets from mirrors, secondary summaries and planned empirical programs were not used as results. No exhaustive Crossmark/retraction-database or full version-diff audit is claimed.

## Material changes versus unchanged conclusions

- N19: Yao Zhao, OUP DOI 10.1093/rssdat/udag004; online 2026-11-13, accepted manuscript, not final typeset version. Abstract separates latent drivers of hedging and mentions a pre-specified replication; no replication sample/effect/data verified. Direct HTTP403, web service recovered official abstract.
- N20: Debu Sinha, Findings ACL2026, July; older formal publication newly reviewed. Official PDF records parser change and 45 repaired items; common 555-item evaluation set differs from 600-item released set. Author rerun/revision, not a new independent replication or newly dated erratum. Exact correction event date not established.
- N21: arXiv2611.13414v1 submitted Nov10; official history and HTML methods/limitations. Zero marginal signal cost is conditional on already running SMC; code/log release is a future statement. Original RTX A6000 results are not MPS results.
- N22: arXiv2611.17041v1 submitted Nov12; official history and HTML methods/tables. Shared-credit vs LEAD-RL accuracy/critical-step comparison verified. Report utility is not causal contribution; critical-path step cost is not elapsed seconds. Metadata/body author spelling difference noted.
- These four are new to this review, not first published today. No previously tracked preprint was silently promoted to formal publication. No new formal retraction/recent erratum/independent replication event verified in the searched material.
- R1/R3/R7 evaluation conditions supplemented; R2/R4/R5/R6 core conclusions maintained. Technical mechanisms do not establish human reliance/agency/ownership or synthetic-to-human validity. N20 supports correct-correction vs misleading-pressure separation already present in the baseline analysis.
- 48 evidence records include 2024-first-public background P07/P08 and records with untraced first-public dates. Preserve existing publication/version/access limitations, including P16's 8-versus-9 model descriptions. IDs belong to the Nov10 seven-axis review, not the separate Nov8 ten-topic register.

## Source and numerical checks

53 direct HTTP requests: 51 HTTP200, P04 and N19 HTTP403. These comprise 48 evidence URLs plus artifact/body/home/prior-page checks. URL success does not imply fulltext verification. All exposed citation titles match their registered normalized titles; missing metadata is not marked as a successful identity match. CSV preserves access level. Official web recovery for P04/N19 is separately recorded.

Additional source URLs:

- https://academic.oup.com/rssdat/advance-article/doi/10.1093/rssdat/udag004/9041060?searchresult=1
- https://aclanthology.org/2026.findings-acl.1759.pdf
- https://github.com/debu-sinha/sycobench-600/blob/main/README.md (blob 2c3cb638ec0a6a757803b6088f9f12a458ac63e5)
- https://github.com/debu-sinha/sycobench-600/blob/main/docs/REPRODUCIBILITY.md (blob f6f338d19ee3a7c41f98b3599efc19fa4aaf80b7)
- https://huggingface.co/datasets/dsinha/sycobench-600 (official author link; dataset bytes not downloaded)
- https://arxiv.org/html/2611.13414v1 (methods, setup, limitations)
- https://arxiv.org/html/2611.17041v1 (methods, critical-step definitions, controlled comparisons)

Every numerical statement is author-reported or metadata; no model, participant, independent reproduction or RL training experiment was run. Seven falsification plans are proposals, including offline logs and reduced MPS inference. Public files require download/license/schema/hash checks before execution. Runtime budgets are planned, not measured. External GPU/API use is not required by the proposed local workflow.

## Editorial and QA

Reread publisher instructions and all six mandatory editorial/typography/diagram/highlight/publication references. Four bundled CSS assets embedded in full and correct order. English title, Korean body, YAML at byte1, layout null, date2026-11-16, categories [artificial intelligence], exactly two existing tags. Responsive styles, font roles and fallbacks, hero-immediate static SVG, local diagram/table scroll regions, four semantic underline levels with textual legend, source/interpretation/proposal distinctions.

Static checks passed: valid HTML nesting, unique IDs, all internal/ARIA references, SVG XML, 77 perspectives in exact 11-step order, 48 unique evidence IDs, highlight metadata, no script or Liquid dependence. Diagram retains minimum1020px local viewport for effective14px+ labels. Desktop1440/mobile390 render was attempted but Playwright's Chromium executable is absent; no visual inspection is claimed. Draft and outputs retained in date-scoped assets for repository publication.

Commit/Pages verification is recorded in the shared watch_state separately after content commit construction. Initial Nov10 article and all other posts are untouched. Only today's HTML, eight companion evidence/analysis/audit files and scoped watch_state are intended for commit.

Audit completed UTC: 2026-11-16T01:17:43.192664+00:00
