# Seven-frontier HAI watch · 2026-11-18 KST

## Authoritative inputs and scope

2025-01-01 through execution morning2026-11-18 KST. Recent14-day overlap November4–18. Reread original HAI-research-trends.md in full (53 lines), connected GitHub baselineNov10, latestNov17 post, 50-record evidence register, scoped seven-frontiers/watch_state and _config.yml. No reliance on scratch as source authority; local scripts only reuse formatting helpers. Baseline blob62fef19e85fd336539628a48b749b982f610606d preserved. Today target initially404. One stable target filename only; no automation created.

Defaultbranch actually master, unprotected; rulesets[]. Root AGENTS.md,_posts/AGENTS.md,CONTRIBUTING.md404. RecentNov16/17 post conventions inspected. Live tag anchors #agentic+ai,#foundation+models verified. Permalink /:year/:month/:day/:title.html; timezoneAsia/Seoul. PriorNov17 live HTTP200 with expected title verified independently of today's Pages deployment.

## Searches executed

Recent engine, recency14:

- LLM sycophancy overreliance research November2026
- agentic workflow control human oversight November2026 paper
- LLM uncertainty expression calibration November2026 research
- contestable AI research November2026
- AI provenance contribution ownership research November2026
- synthetic human interaction evaluation November2026 paper
- multi-agent coordination research November17 2026
- sycophancy correction replication2026

Full-period representative searches and targeted follow-up:

- 2025 2026 human AI contestable uncertainty ownership interaction evaluation research
- 2025 2026 multi agent workflow control evaluation human sycophancy research
- Exact title: Unprompted coordination through shared memory in LLM agents: a locked two-implementation replication and extension
- PACE2611.17610 and AI and the Responsibility-Bearing Status of Authorship

Non-exhaustive retrieval: no systematic search recall or complete Crossmark/retraction database audit claimed. Do not turn planned studies, consultations, indexes, mirror dates or news coverage into completed empirical findings.

## New review records and version evidence

N25, arXiv2611.12412: official metadata/history directly recoveredHTTP200 after web reader failed. v1 submitted2026-11-09 13:43:52UTC; v2 submitted2026-11-16 08:28:31UTC. Both HTML versions inspected for method/threats/data statement and compared. Meaningful publication-resource change: v1 says reference source not released and gives Zenodo23965306; v2 states MIT reference-source release at GPT-Laboratory/emergent-echoes, tagpaper-e1, and gives Zenodo24273453. Do not count a version number alone as a result. Full numerical/PDF diff and complete original-data verification not performed. Corresponding primary URLs:

- https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.12412
- https://arxiv.org/html/2611.12412v1
- https://arxiv.org/html/2611.12412v2
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24273453 (paper's availability declaration; archive bytes not downloaded)
- https://github.com/GPT-Laboratory/emergent-echoes/tree/paper-e1

Connected GitHub fetched paper-e1 README (blob115d456daffb778ee21192176eaf53e547e35ec8); root LICENSE at that tag404. Repository/tag presence verified; MIT licensing remains a paper statement, not independently verified. Implementation rebuild is by two researchers in the same group without shared code; it is not an independent outside-team reproduction. The paper discloses lock-order deviations, partial information exposure, key collisions and parser/endpoint differences. No human participants; cross-agent read is distinct from influence and communication intent.

N26, arXiv2611.17610v1 submitted2026-11-13 00:18:25UTC. Official abstract/history and HTML sections on methods, baseline categories, extraction, limitations and analysis protocol inspected. Nine-study selective synthesis,516 unique configurations/531 extracted rows; sample/budget-matched contrast mean−0.042 is an unweighted descriptive comparison, not a universal causal effect. Initial5 studies selected without search protocol; analysis not preregistered; correlation and small sample assumptions disclosed. Primary:

- https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.17610
- https://arxiv.org/html/2611.17610v1
- https://github.com/mahmoudsajjadi/pace (README blob13649acd5924ccbe997967743a58d232ba093009)

Current README states Apache2.0 code and CCBY4.0 data, additional open-weight experiments and expanded toolkit. These are not silently merged with the v1 paper's experiments. No code/data execution or full artifact licensing verification performed. CPU ledger checks and reduced CPU/MPS comparisons are proposed adaptations.

N27, Caterina Moruzzi, DOI10.1007/s13347-026-01235-w, Philosophy & Technology39,225, published/VOR2026-11-14. Official publisher abstract, argument, conclusion and metadata inspected. Normative ACE framework (intentional agency,guided control,relational expression) is not a human experiment or legal-right classifier. Primary https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13347-026-01235-w . Journal cover date must not replace onlineVOR date.

All three new to the review, not first published today. N25 first public precedesNov10 baseline; itsv2 is later. N26/N27 published after baseline but before last successful search. New review findings do not imply last24h publication events. No tracked-paper new official retraction/erratum/outside-team replication event verified in bounded search; N25 two-implementation result separately identified.

## Access, preservation and experiments

Initial52 direct checks (50 evidence URLs plus home/priorpost):50 HTTP200, P04/N19HTTP403. Yesterday's503s recovered; success does not imply fulltext verification. Additional7 primary/artifact/body requests allHTTP200, recorded separately: N25,B25v1,N26,B26v1,N27,code26,B25v2. Connected GitHub artifact calls separate. Prior dated connectivity caveats replaced by today's access status; scientific limitations retained; Nov17 audit remains preserved.

53 evidence records include 2024-first-public P07/P08 background exceptions and untraced first-public dates. P16 formal8/preprint9model discrepancy and other previous limitations preserved. IDs belong to the Nov10 seven-axis program, not the Nov8 ten-topic register.

No participant/model study, independent numerical reproduction or RL training run performed. All numeric findings are source-author reports. New proposals isolate shared/private/no-store channels, baseline compute parity, and contribution-log integrity on CPU/MPS. Public artifact/license/schema/hash and smoke execution checks precede implementation; budgets are plans, not measured performance. Technical tests cannot establish actual overreliance, subjective ownership, human contestation efficacy or normative authorship.

## Editorial and publication QA

Current publisher instructions and all six mandatory editorial/font/diagram/highlight/publication references reread. Four bundled CSS assets embedded byte-complete and in required order. English title,Korean body,mandatory YAML atbyte1,layoutnull,date2026-11-18,categories[artificial intelligence],two current tags. Font roles and fallbacks preserved. Content-specific four-node evidence-path SVG immediately afterhero,local focusable minimum1020px diagram scrolling,14px+ meaningful labels. Four highlight classes match textual importance mapping; importance not evidence confidence.

Static checks passed:77 perspectives in exact11-step order for all7axes,53 unique evidence IDs,HTML nesting,SVG XML,unique IDs,internal/ARIA references,highlight metadata,CSS ordering,no scripts/Liquid dependence. Playwright launch attempted:Chromium executable absent; no1440px/390px visual verification claimed.

Publish only today's HTML,eight date-scoped companion files,and scoped watch_state. Preserve baseline and all other posts. Separate content commit and state commit advanced together with expected-head lease. Search completion,repository publication and public Pages deployment are separate states; do not claim public deployment while pending.
